our best investment

In his budget address a few weeks ago, governor Fortuño referred to public, affordable higher education as a “privilege” that Puerto Rico provides to its students  at no small cost to its citizens.  To reinforce the message, he compared UPR tuition prices to the much higher ones of other, private, higher education institutions in the island, and of colleges and universities in the United States.

In an  “us vs them” move seemingly designed to conceptually place responsible tax payers against  protesting students, he stated that “tuition paid by students, when they do pay, is but a 3% of the university’s budget…the rest is paid by us taxpayers. Which is why our people, just and noble, yes, but also democratic and respectful of law and order,  get upset when they see what we have all seen in the University these past two days.” As the strike grew bigger and more complicated, today involving all of the 11 campuses, a number of public and private citizens have echoed the governor’s general message, portraying the students as selfish, privileged, disorderly, and “ideologically” driven.  As I write this column, the president of the UPR’s Board of Regents is stating, on the radio, that the striking students are “breaking down the institution”.

At the heart of this image is the idea that the university is too inexpensive for the individual students and too expensive for the state, thus rendering student complaints about the elimination of tuition waivers, and their insistence that tuition rates stay low, as shallow.  I propose we examine this notion. Is the university really “too cheap”?  Is it a “cost” to the state?  “Cheap” and “expensive” are relative terms, and they arise from comparing the costs of the UPR with other institutions.  However, is the comparison with private institutions in the island, and with public and private universities in the US, an appropriate comparison?

Private institutions in the island have helped the country meet an increasing demand for higher education degrees but in terms of efficiency and value, economic studies have shown that the University of Puerto Rico,with  double the graduation rate and producing 95% of the island’s research output, represents the best return on investment for public funds.

Universities across the United States, a country traditionally known for its excellence in higher education,  are experiencing problems that the states are concerned with.  Two (related) ones are 1)access issues faced  by minorities and low-income students and  2)the production of STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Math) degrees.  Access problems are in great part due precisely to increasing tuition costs in 4 year colleges and universities.  STEM degrees hover around 20% of US degrees, at a time when the country desperately needs to increase the domestic STEM workforce.  Mainland universities have an average of only 14% of their student body qualifying for need-based Pell Grants.  A number of efforts in the United States, including the intensive use of federal ARRA funds, are directed at increasing the number of underrepresented students and of STEM degrees.

In contrast, at the University of Puerto Rico, 40% of the degrees are STEM, and two-thirds of its student body qualifies for need-based aid.  The UPR produces today 16% of the Hispanic STEM workforce in the US.  Historically, the people of Puerto Rico have viewed their public university not as a cost or as a burden but as an investment-the kind of investment most needed in times of economic crisis.

The governor is fond of the “family” metaphor.  He often compares Puerto Rico and its current fiscal crisis with a family that needs to make hard choices to face periods of economic crisis, and wonders out loud about why the  UPR cannot seem to be able to “tighten its belt” like so many families have done around the island.  But even within the metaphor, choosing to take resources away from the public university in times of fiscal crisis would be akin to taking away children’s educational opportunities.  Few families would agree with this choice.

The constitution of Puerto Rico (section 5, art.2) provides for a free public education system covering grades 1 through 12.  This was in 1952, when a high school diploma brought a certain amount of prestige and a number of job opportunities.  It could easily be argued that what the high school diploma meant for the fifties, the college degree means for today.

Affordable, public higher education cannot be seen as cost or expense, but as value. It is one of those things where Puerto Rico consistently “lo hace mejor.”  It is one of the best investments we have made as a collectivity, as a society. Let us protect it.

8 comentarios en “our best investment

  1. Very good article. I feel the need to thank you. It is very difficult to keep track of the things that matter in PR right now from afar. Not to mention hard to find clear and concise facts about whats happening. I hope that we can find a new formulas to resolve this problem and that a college education in Puerto Rico will still be affordable by everyone in the coming decades. Let us brace ourselves… I fear that a good education will not be the only thing many countries will starve from in a near future.
    Saludos desde Barcelona.

    Me gusta

  2. Right on! If our future were a tree, we are going to let this administration chop away wood (for chairs?) until we’re left with a dead tree. No more shade, fruits, no more future. Only education will help us not just deal, but survive in the difficult times ahead. But Fortuño, named flojuño by those who have not heard about reaganomics, knows very well which buttons to press, as you’ve just said. Salud, suerte y ánimo.

    Me gusta

  3. Muy buen artículo. Quería hacerte una pregunta. ¿Tenés idea de qué porcentage de graduados de la Universidad se va a EE.UU. y se queda allí? No es por condenar las decisiones personales, sino más bien porque no sé qué porcentaje de efectividad hay en las políticas estatales de retención de personas calificadas dentro de la isla. Busco pero no encuentro los datos. Estamos debatiendo algunas cosas parecidas en mi blog y otras no tanto. Si querés pasate a chusmear. Saludos

    Me gusta

  4. Hola, desparejo! Disculpa la tardanza en responder…No tengo el dato que buscas. Pero si podemos decir (sorry, no tengo acentos ahora mismo, se me han perdido) que producimos suficientes como para que el 16% de la fuerza laboral STEM hispana en Estados Unidos sea graduada de nuestro sistema UPR. La cosa se complica con lo que llaman “revolving door migration” porque la migracion puertorriquena tiende a ser muy flexible…Te vas, regresas, te vas, regresas…En todos los sectores de clase.

    Alguna vez lei de programas argentinos que incentivan el regreso de los migrantes, cierto? raices, creo que se llamaba uno…

    Me gusta

  5. Hola Rima. Gracias por la respuesta. El plan que conozco pertenece al CONICET y se llama “Reinsercion” (http://www.conicet.gov.ar/becas/reinsercion/curso/index.php). Son 24 meses de beca para los que vuelven de una estadia en el exterior. Creo que el que mencionas como Raices es uno nuevo del Ministerio de Ciencia y Tecnologia para repatriar cientificos. Si, se que es alto el numero de graduados de UPR trabajando en EEUU. Y un poco por ahi venia la discusion que teniamos en el blog con algunos amigos boricuas. Y tenia que ver con que traba al desarrollo economico mas o menos autonomo de la isla podria representar esa gran cantidad de universitarios fuera de PR. Es decir, en que grado podia afectar al desarrollo economico interno, si es que era un numero lo suficientemente alto. Pero en la discusion nos manejabamos con suposiciones a falta de numeros. Bueno, como siempre, muy bueno tu blog. Saludos

    Me gusta


Introduce tus datos o haz clic en un icono para iniciar sesión:

Logo de WordPress.com

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de WordPress.com. Cerrar sesión /  Cambiar )

Google photo

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Google. Cerrar sesión /  Cambiar )

Imagen de Twitter

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Twitter. Cerrar sesión /  Cambiar )

Foto de Facebook

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Facebook. Cerrar sesión /  Cambiar )

Conectando a %s